In July this year, I completed the first draft of my manuscript! It felt glorious to reach this milestone after the months of emotional ups and downs which typically comprise the development of a first draft. Luckily, I had the support of the Shut Up & Write community throughout the process.
But a completed first draft is still a long way from being publishable. Each time I wavered during the drafting process, I reminded myself that I could always fix it later. This idea was the wind behind my wings as I speed-drafted the raw, messy version of my manuscript over the course of seven months.
Well, now it’s “later.” How on earth am I going to embark upon the Herculean task of “fixing” my draft? Minor corrections like typos are one thing, but what I have in front of me is a massive document in need of a full round of developmental self-editing. This is a stage of revision that involves complex changes like reordering plot, deepening relationships between characters, and even getting rid of some characters altogether. Where should I even start?
If you’re feeling similarly overwhelmed about your first draft, you’re not alone. Here are some of the ways I’ve chosen to structure my editing process.
1. Let It Sit
Gaining perspective on your novel requires that you wait a little while before jumping into revisions. But how long should you wait? Some authors can start revising within a few days after finishing a draft, while others prefer to wait for a couple of weeks or even as long as a few months. You’ll know you’ve let it sit for the right amount of time once you can pick up your draft and feel a little surprised at what’s on the page. This means you’re reading it with fresh eyes, and it’s a good time to start editing.
2. Find Your Novel’s Purpose
Whether you’ve crafted a new fantasy universe of your own or set your novel in our ordinary reality, you are still the creator of your novel’s world. Wielding this power means you get to decide what is most important. What are the biggest things you want your audience to take away from reading your novel? Do you want them biting their nails while traversing the twists and turns in your plot, or would you rather they laugh and cry alongside your protagonist? Typically, you will have multiple goals for the impact you want to have on your readers, but getting specific with your primary objectives is critical to guiding the revision process.
Keep in mind that goals can change during the drafting process. You may, for example, have started out thinking your book was going to be an epic fantasy novel, but then found yourself gravitating instead towards an intimate portrait of your main character’s struggles. That’s okay! But take the time to reflect on the overall imprint you want to leave on your reader before you start revising.
3. Read It Through
Once you have a sense of what kind of novel you’re aiming for, do a full read-through without making any changes. Set aside a few days to do this, with time allotted for taking copious notes in a separate document.
As you read your draft, take notes on what you like and don’t like about each chapter. Do this sequentially so you can read chapter-by-chapter notes on what’s working well and what needs work. Remember, the question of “what needs work” has to do with your desired impact. If you’re aiming for a fast-paced thriller but your plot is sleepy in places, then the tension in your plot needs work. If you’re aspiring to a poignant, heartbreaking tale about people living in a small town, but your characters feel one-dimensional, then your character development needs work. Even though this will be your second draft, you can’t fix everything at once, so prioritize core changes and leave a more extensive wishlist in a separate section for each chapter.
4. List Your Problems
After you have your chapter notes, do a read-through of those and sort the to-do items into the following categories:
- Example: “In chapters 7 and 8, my characters are just sitting around doing nothing.”
- Example: “Chapters 11 and 18 don’t end in a compelling way.”
- Example: “The ending of my book feels too drawn out.”
Example: “The forest and the lake can’t logically be so close together.”
Example: “It’s hard to visualize my protagonist’s workplace, where a lot of the action happens.”
- Example: “My protagonist’s motivation doesn’t seem realistic.”
- Example: “I never explained why my protagonist is bonded to her best friend.”
- Example: “There are too many characters at the beginning, and it’s hard to tell them apart.”
- Example: “My dialogue has a lot of jokes, but I’d rather my book be suspenseful and inspire feelings of thrill and fear.”
- Example: “In Chapters 1-3, I overuse the word ‘creepy’ in lieu of actually showing what makes the situation creepy.”
Organizing your insights in this way gives you what I call “The Problems List,” which clearly lays out everything you want to fix in your second draft.
5. Find Solutions
Now it’s time to brainstorm solutions to each problem in your list. First, make a copy of your Problems List and name it “The Solutions List.”
Then, let yourself imagine multiple ways to fix each of the problems in your manuscript, jotting them down in as organized a way as you can manage. Work through this list one item at a time, and don’t be afraid to take as long as you need to brainstorm solutions for some of the hardest problems.
Finally, for each problem you’ve identified, go through and select the solution you like best and which will be the most compatible with the other solutions. For example, if you decide your protagonist needs a stronger motivation, and you choose to go with “revenge against the childhood best friend who bullied her,” make sure that you’re not using the childhood best friend in a conflicting role, such as a shoulder to cry on in Chapter 5, for example.
After you’ve picked the winning solution to each problem, you have your Solutions List! You can think of it as an outline for your second draft.
This stage can take a long time, from weeks to even months. But the work you put in during this phase will pay off in hours saved later down the line.
6. Start Your Second Draft
Finally, you’re ready to start revising! Be sure to make a copy of your first draft so you can use it as a reference if necessary.
Personally, I prefer to work in non-chronological order so I can jump around and implement my solutions in order of priority. If I need my villain to come in at the midpoint in order to justify all of my heroine’s prior actions, I want to be able to really see and feel the impact of what my villain is doing before tackling the nitty-gritty of my heroine’s decisions. In this case, I would relocate and revise the scene where my villain comes in before I revise the earlier chapters which reference the oncoming threat.
As you revise, you may discover additional problems you’d like to address, but I say, save those for the next draft. Jot them down in separate document so you don’t forget them. Perfect should never become the enemy of the good, so keep marching one step at a time until you’ve finished your second draft.
7. Seek Feedback
Once you’re done with your second draft, you can celebrate how far you’ve come in your journey! Each draft is a labor of love, and the fact that you’ve now done two drafts is nothing to sneeze at.
Before moving onto another round of edits, you will likely want some feedback from other readers. This ensures that you don’t end up changing things that are working well, and overlooking issues that you didn’t have enough perspective to see.
Check out our articles on how to get feedback on your writing and working with a beta reader for even more resources!
What do you think? Let us know in the comments below, and be sure to sign up for our Newsletter for more guidance on writing.
Hi, this is the most helpful article I’ve found on this topic. Thanks for sharing your tips!
That’s great! I’m so happy to hear that 🙂
This is my first time writing a novel, but I’ve heard that instead of simply revising a first draft, some writers open a new document and totally re-write the whole thing (with problems and solutions in mind). What’s your opinion on revising versus rewriting?
This is a great question! Since every writer’s process is so different, I’d suggest trying both approaches for one chapter, and seeing which one works better. Once you’ve done this test, you’ll likely have a better sense of which editing approach (rewriting the whole thing vs. revising each chapter) works better for you for the rest of your manuscript.
This is very helpful. I’m almost done with my first draft and I know I have threads I started but never finished, threads and characters that need to go away, and things to rearrange. I was thinking about writing a one line synopsis of each chapter: What I’m trying to show with the characters and what part of the plot this chapter affects, etc. My idea is that might help me reorganize the chapters into a better sequence, and maybe give me a better view of the story from 10,000 feet. Sort of outlining the story after the fact. Have you ever done anything like this?
The one-line synopsis of each chapter is a great idea! I’ve definitely used this technique. It’s a tried-and-true method of getting that high-level view of your plot movements, as you mention. So glad you were able to use this article to inform your novel editing process!
What a great article, thank you! I wrote my first draft back in 2020, and I found the idea of editing so daunting I’ve been putting it off. I picked it up recently and loved re-reading it, but didn’t know what to do next. This gives me some great ideas! Time to roll my sleeves up and get stuck in, with your help. Thank you!
Thank you for this article . I will try this method .
This is some good advice – thank you
Leave a comment